Back to Reference
No items found.
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.
Watch a demoTake a product tour
June 6, 2024
XX min read

Nmbrs vs Square Payroll


In today’s fast-paced business environment, efficient HR and payroll management is crucial for organizational success. Two prominent HRIS (Human Resource Information System) tools in the market are Nmbrs and Square Payroll. Nmbrs BV is a knowledge-intensive IT-service provider that delivers online HR and payroll applications, utilizing the newest Microsoft technologies. Square Payroll, on the other hand, is an online payroll service that has gained the trust of small businesses due to its user-friendly interface and efficient payroll management.

Comparing these HRIS tools is essential for businesses looking to streamline their HR and payroll processes to improve efficiency and accuracy. This in-depth comparison will help you understand the strengths and weaknesses of each tool, guiding you to make an informed decision based on your organizational needs.

Nmbrs Overview

Nmbrs BV stands out as a comprehensive HRIS solution designed to cater to the complex needs of medium to large enterprises. By leveraging advanced Microsoft technologies, Nmbrs aims at providing seamless HR and payroll services with a focus on flexibility and precision.

Key Features

  • Employee Self-Service: Empowers employees to access their payroll information, request time off, and update personal details through a user-friendly portal.
  • Comprehensive Payroll Management: Automates payroll processing with precise calculations, tax compliance, and multi-currency support.
  • Time & Attendance Tracking: Integrates with various systems to monitor employee attendance, simplifying schedule management and reducing errors.
  • Advanced Reporting: Offers customizable reports and analytics to gain insights into payroll expenses, labor costs, and HR metrics.
  • Integrations: Seamlessly integrates with popular ERP and accounting systems to ensure data consistency across platforms.
  • Security: Employs robust security measures including encryption and role-based access controls to protect sensitive employee data.

Square Payroll Overview

Square Payroll appeals primarily to small businesses by offering a straightforward, easy-to-use payroll service. Known for its seamless integration with other Square services, it provides a holistic approach to managing employee payments and compliance.

Key Features

  • Automatic Payroll Tax Filings: Handles all federal and state tax filings, ensuring compliance and saving time.
  • Direct Deposits & Payments: Facilitates direct deposits for employee wages and contractor payments with ease.
  • Employee Benefits Management: Enables businesses to manage health insurance, retirement plans, and other employee benefits through integrated partners.
  • Time Tracking Integration: Syncs with time tracking applications to streamline payroll calculations based on actual hours worked.
  • User-Friendly Interface: Designed with simplicity in mind, making it easy for small business owners to navigate and manage payroll tasks.
  • Exceptional Support: Provides reliable customer support, ensuring users receive timely assistance with any payroll-related issues.


Both Nmbrs and Square Payroll are robust HRIS tools that aim to simplify and automate payroll processes and HR management. Some key similarities include:

  • Payroll Automation: Both tools automate payroll calculations, deductions, and tax filings to reduce manual workload and errors.
  • Employee Self-Service: Each platform offers an employee portal where staff can access payroll information and manage personal details.
  • Compliance: Ensures compliance with federal and state regulations, helping businesses avoid penalties.
  • Time Tracking: Integrates with time tracking software to accurately process employee hours and pay.
  • Focus on Security: Employs strong security measures to protect sensitive employee and company data.


While Nmbrs and Square Payroll share many similarities, they also cater to different business needs and scales.

  • Target Audience: Nmbrs is tailored for medium to large enterprises with complex HR and payroll requirements, whereas Square Payroll is designed for small businesses seeking a straightforward payroll solution.
  • Technology Basis: Nmbrs leverages advanced Microsoft technologies, providing flexibility and scalability for growing businesses. Square Payroll focuses on ease of use and seamless integration with Square’s ecosystem.
  • Feature Complexity: Nmbrs offers a wide range of advanced features like detailed reporting and multi-currency support which may be unnecessary for smaller businesses. Square Payroll provides essential features in a simplified manner.
  • Employee Benefits Management: Nmbrs has a more comprehensive approach to HR functionalities, including extensive employee benefits management. Square Payroll, although effective, may have more limited options in this domain.
  • Customizability: Nmbrs allows for a higher degree of customization, suited for businesses with specific needs. Square Payroll’s simplicity could limit customization but benefits those who prefer an out-of-the-box solution.


Pros and Cons



  • Highly customizable and scalable, ideal for growing enterprises.
  • Advanced reporting capabilities with in-depth analytics.
  • Robust integration options ensure seamless data flow across systems.
  • Comprehensive payroll feature set with multi-currency support.
  • Strong security protocols ensuring data protection.


  • May be overly complex for small businesses.
  • Higher cost compared to simpler payroll solutions.
  • Steeper learning curve due to extensive feature set.

Square Payroll


  • User-friendly interface designed for non-experts.
  • Efficient automatic tax filing and compliance management.
  • Seamless integration with other Square products.
  • Cost-effective solution for small businesses.
  • Reliable customer support and assistance.


  • Limited advanced features compared to more comprehensive HRIS tools.
  • Less suitable for medium to large enterprises with complex needs.
  • Reduced customization options may not fit all business models.

Use Cases

Ideal Scenarios for Nmbrs

  • Large Enterprises: Businesses with a large workforce requiring advanced payroll management and HR functionalities.
  • Multi-national Companies: Organizations operating in multiple countries needing multi-currency payroll support and compliance management.
  • Data-Driven Businesses: Companies that demand detailed payroll reports and analytics for strategic decision-making.
  • Integration-Heavy Environments: Firms that rely on various ERP and financial systems for their operations.

Ideal Scenarios for Square Payroll

  • Small Businesses: Ideal for small business owners looking for an affordable and user-friendly payroll solution.
  • Square Ecosystem Users: Businesses already using Square products can leverage seamless integration for a comprehensive payroll management system.
  • Startups: New enterprises needing a straightforward payroll system without the complexity of advanced features.
  • Limited HR Resources: Companies with minimal HR staff who need an easy-to-use, automated payroll solution.


In comparing Nmbrs and Square Payroll, it’s clear that both tools offer unique strengths tailored to different business needs. Nmbrs, with its advanced features, customization options, and scalability, is well-suited for medium to large enterprises requiring an extensive and flexible HRIS solution. In contrast, Square Payroll provides a simplified, user-friendly payroll service ideal for small businesses and startups, especially those already within the Square ecosystem.

Choosing between Nmbrs and Square Payroll ultimately depends on your organization’s size, complexity of HR needs, and existing system integrations. For large enterprises aiming for detailed analytics and robust functionalities, Nmbrs offers a comprehensive solution. Small businesses seeking ease of use and cost-effectiveness will find Square Payroll to be a perfect fit. Assess your company’s specific requirements and opt for the tool that aligns best with your operational goals and growth plans.

Key takeaways 🔑🥡🍕

Written by
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.

Learn more tools and terminology re: workplace knowledge