Back to Reference
No items found.
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.
Watch a demoTake a product tour
June 6, 2024
XX min read

Factorial vs Square Payroll


Choosing the right Human Resource Information System (HRIS) tool is critical for small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) aiming to streamline their HR processes. Two prominent players in this space are Factorial and Square Payroll. 

Factorial is a comprehensive HR software designed to manage time, talent, and documents in a centralized system. It helps save time, eliminate mistakes, and guide companies toward success. As a cloud-based solution tailored for SMBs, Factorial replaces the need for spreadsheets with a simple and intuitive interface that optimizes and digitizes manual processes.

Square Payroll, on the other hand, is an online payroll service trusted by small businesses. It focuses on simplifying payroll management, ensuring compliance, and providing a seamless experience for both employers and employees.

Comparing these HRIS tools is essential to find the best fit for your business needs, whether you require a comprehensive HR solution or a specialized payroll service.

Factorial Overview

Key Features

Factorial offers a wide range of features designed to handle various HR tasks efficiently:

  • Time Tracking: Automated time tracking for employees, including clock-ins, clock-outs, and time-off requests.
  • Talent Management: Tools for performance reviews, goal setting, and employee development.
  • Document Management: Centralized storage for HR documents, ensuring easy access and management.
  • Employee Self-Service: Employees can update their information, request leave, and access necessary documents through a user-friendly portal.
  • Analytics and Reporting: Comprehensive reports and analytics to help HR managers make informed decisions.
  • Compliance Management: Tools to ensure the company adheres to labor laws and regulations.

Square Payroll Overview

Key Features

Square Payroll focuses on providing an easy-to-use payroll solution for small businesses:

  • Automated Payroll Processing: Simplifies calculation and distribution of employee wages, taxes, and benefits.
  • Tax Management: Handles federal, state, and local payroll tax filings and payments automatically.
  • Direct Deposit: Provides direct deposit options for employees, ensuring timely payments.
  • Employee Self-Onboarding: Employees can onboard themselves, input their information, and access their pay stubs online.
  • Benefits and Deductions Management: Easily manage employee benefits and deductions.
  • Integration with Square POS: Seamlessly integrates with Square Point of Sale, making it ideal for retail and hospitality businesses.


Both Factorial and Square Payroll share several similarities as HRIS tools:

  • Cloud-Based Solutions: Both tools are cloud-based, ensuring easy access and updates from anywhere.
  • Employee Self-Service: Each platform offers self-service options for employees, allowing them to manage their own information and requests.
  • Compliance Management: Both tools include features to help companies stay compliant with labor laws and regulations.
  • Scalability: Designed to cater to the needs of SMBs, both Factorial and Square Payroll can scale as businesses grow.


While both tools offer valuable HR solutions, there are notable differences between Factorial and Square Payroll:

  • Scope of Features: Factorial provides a broad range of HR functionalities beyond payroll, including time tracking, talent management, and document management. Square Payroll, however, is specialized in payroll processing and related tasks.
  • Integration Focus: Factorial integrates with various HR and productivity tools, while Square Payroll is specifically designed to integrate seamlessly with the Square Point of Sale system.
  • User Interface: Factorial features an intuitive interface suitable for comprehensive HR management, whereas Square Payroll offers a simplified, user-friendly interface focused on payroll tasks.
  • Pricing Models: The pricing structures may differ, with Factorial typically offering more expansive packages based on HR needs and Square Payroll providing straightforward pricing geared towards payroll services.

Pros and Cons



  • Comprehensive HR management covering multiple facets of HR processes.
  • Intuitive interface and user-friendly employee self-service portal.
  • Robust analytics and reporting capabilities.
  • Centralized document management improves accessibility and organization.
  • Time tracking and talent management features support employee development.


  • May have a steeper learning curve for users needing only payroll services.
  • Potential higher cost compared to specialized payroll solutions.

Square Payroll


  • Simple, easy-to-use interface tailored for payroll management.
  • Automated tax filings and payments ensure compliance.
  • Direct deposit and self-onboarding streamline payroll processes.
  • Seamless integration with Square POS makes it ideal for retail and hospitality industries.
  • Competitive pricing for businesses focused solely on payroll services.


  • Limited to payroll and related tasks, lacking broader HR functionalities.
  • Integration options may be less flexible compared to all-encompassing HR tools.
  • May not be suitable for businesses needing extensive HR management features beyond payroll.

Use Cases


Ideal for businesses looking for an all-in-one HR solution that covers various HR processes from time tracking to talent management. Factorial is suitable for SMBs that require robust HR management tools, centralized document handling, and detailed analytics to inform HR decisions.

Square Payroll:

Perfect for small businesses focused on simplifying payroll processes. Square Payroll is particularly well-suited for companies using Square POS, such as retail stores and restaurants, looking for a straightforward payroll solution with seamless integration and automated compliance management.


Choosing between Factorial and Square Payroll depends on your business’s specific HR needs. 

Factorial stands out as a comprehensive HR solution, offering a wide range of features addressing time, talent, and document management. It is best suited for SMBs requiring an all-encompassing HR tool to simplify administrative processes, enhance employee development, and ensure compliance.

Square Payroll, in contrast, excels as a dedicated payroll service, providing a user-friendly interface and seamless payroll processing capabilities. It is ideal for small businesses, especially those utilizing Square POS, focused on efficient payroll management and automated tax compliance.

When deciding between the two, consider whether your primary need is an extensive HR management system (Factorial) or a specialized payroll solution (Square Payroll). Each tool offers unique benefits that cater to different aspects of HR and payroll management, ensuring you find the best fit for your business requirements.

Key takeaways 🔑🥡🍕

Written by
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.

Learn more tools and terminology re: workplace knowledge