Back to Reference
No items found.
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.
Watch a demoTake a product tour
June 6, 2024
XX min read

Humaans vs Square Payroll


When selecting a Human Resource Information System (HRIS) for your business, it's crucial to understand how different tools can meet your organization’s needs. Two such tools are Humaans and Square Payroll, each offering unique features tailored to specific business requirements.

Humaans is an HRIS built from the ground up to be the foundation layer of an organization's HR tech stack, helping modern HR teams at fast-growing companies to onboard, manage, and grow their employees through fast workflows, automation, and quick access to data.

Square Payroll, on the other hand, is an online payroll service trusted by small businesses for its ease of use and integration capabilities.

A detailed comparison of these tools will help you make an informed decision on which is the best fit for your specific needs.

Humaans Overview

Humaans is designed to streamline HR processes for fast-growing companies, focusing on ease of use and robust functionality. 

Key Features

  1. Onboarding Automation: Simplifies the onboarding process with automated tasks and checklists to ensure nothing is overlooked.  
  2. Employee Management: Unified dashboard for managing employee records, contracts, compensation, and benefits.
  3. Workflow Automation: Set up automated workflows to handle repetitive HR tasks, freeing up time for strategic activities.
  4. Data Analytics and Reporting: Gain insights into employee data with powerful analytics and reporting features.
  5. Integrations: Seamless integration with other HR and productivity tools to create a cohesive HR tech stack.
  6. Employee Growth Tracking: Tools to track and manage employee performance, training, and development plans.

Square Payroll Overview

Square Payroll is an intuitive payroll solution favored among small businesses for its simplicity and integration with the Square ecosystem. 

Key Features

  1. Automated Payroll: Simplifies payroll processing with automated calculations and tax filings.
  2. Employee Self-Service: Allows employees to view their paystubs, request time off, and update personal information through a self-service portal.
  3. Direct Deposit: Offers direct deposit options to streamline payday.
  4. Tax Reporting: Handles federal, state, and local tax reporting, reducing the administrative burden on small businesses.
  5. Time Tracking: Integrated time tracking to ensure accurate payroll calculations.
  6. Benefits Management: Integrates with benefits providers to manage health insurance, 401(k) plans, and other benefits.


  • Employee Management: Both Humaans and Square Payroll offer robust employee management solutions, including record-keeping and self-service portals for employees.
  • Automation: Both tools provide automation features to simplify repetitive tasks—Humaans focuses on automating HR workflows, while Square Payroll automates payroll and tax calculations.
  • Integration Capabilities: Each tool integrates with various third-party applications, allowing businesses to create a cohesive HR and payroll ecosystem.
  • User-Friendly Interface: Both have user-friendly interfaces designed to minimize the learning curve for users and administrators.


  • Primary Focus: Humaans focuses primarily on holistic HR management, including employee onboarding, performance tracking, and growth management. In contrast, Square Payroll specializes in payroll processing and tax compliance.
  • Target Audience: Humaans is tailored for fast-growing companies looking for comprehensive HR solutions. Square Payroll, however, is designed for small businesses needing an efficient payroll system.
  • Advanced HR Features: Humaans offers advanced HR features like employee growth tracking and detailed data analytics, which are not emphasized in Square Payroll.
  • Benefits Management: While both systems integrate with benefits providers, Humaans offers more extensive HR-related benefits management features compared to Square Payroll.
  • Tax Reporting: Square Payroll comes with built-in tax reporting and filing capabilities, which is a specific strength compared to Humaans’ broader HR focus.

Pros and Cons



  • Comprehensive HR solution covering a wide range of needs from onboarding to employee growth.
  • Advanced data analytics and reporting for better decision-making.
  • High degree of workflow automation reduces manual HR tasks.
  • Seamless integration with multiple HR and productivity tools enhances functionality.
  • User-friendly interface with robust support.


  • May be more than small businesses need if they are only looking for payroll processing.
  • Costs may be higher due to the wide range of features offered.
  • Requires some initial setup to fully leverage its comprehensive features.

Square Payroll


  • Simplifies payroll processing with automated calculations and direct deposit.
  • Comprehensive tax filing features reduce administrative burden.
  • Easy to use, even for businesses without a dedicated HR team.
  • Cost-effective solution for small businesses focusing solely on payroll needs.
  • Smooth integration with the Square ecosystem and other third-party benefits providers.


  • Limited HR features compared to Humaans.
  • Not ideal for larger companies or those needing comprehensive HR management tools.
  • Basic employee management features may not meet the needs of fast-growing companies.

Use Cases


  • Fast-Growing Companies: Ideal for organizations experiencing rapid growth that need a scalable HR solution to manage onboarding, employee performance, and growth.
  • Companies Seeking HR Automation: Perfect for businesses looking to automate HR workflows and free up their HR team to focus on strategic initiatives.
  • Data-Driven Organizations: Excellent for companies that rely on data analytics for decision-making, providing detailed insights into employee metrics and performance.

Square Payroll:

  • Small Businesses: Best suited for small businesses that need a straightforward payroll processing tool with robust tax compliance features.
  • Companies Using Square’s Ecosystem: Ideal for businesses already using other Square products, ensuring seamless integration across the board.
  • Businesses Needing Simplified Tax Reporting: Suitable for organizations that want to reduce the complexity of tax filing and ensure compliance with minimal effort.


Both Humaans and Square Payroll offer valuable features that serve different business needs. Humaans excels as a comprehensive HRIS solution tailored for fast-growing companies seeking to automate HR processes, manage employee growth, and gain insights from advanced analytics. It’s ideal for businesses that require a scalable and versatile HR management tool.

On the other hand, Square Payroll is a streamlined payroll service perfect for small businesses that need efficient payroll processing and robust tax compliance. Its ease of use and integration with the Square ecosystem make it a compelling choice for businesses focused mainly on payroll needs.

When choosing between Humaans and Square Payroll, consider your company’s current size, growth trajectory, and specific HR or payroll needs. Fast-growing companies needing a comprehensive HR solution will find Humaans invaluable, while small businesses seeking a straightforward payroll service will benefit greatly from Square Payroll.

Key takeaways 🔑🥡🍕

Written by
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.

Learn more tools and terminology re: workplace knowledge