Back to Reference
No items found.
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.
Watch a demoTake a product tour
June 6, 2024
XX min read

Sage HR vs Square Payroll


When it comes to managing human resources and payroll, businesses often rely on specialized software solutions to streamline these processes. Sage HR and Square Payroll are two popular tools in the HRIS category known for offering valuable features tailored to meet different business needs. 

Sage HR is an HR software that helps to solve HR challenges and allows businesses to focus on growth and development. It encompasses a comprehensive suite of features designed to manage every aspect of human resource management seamlessly.

Square Payroll, on the other hand, is an online payroll service trusted by numerous small businesses. With a reputation for being user-friendly and efficient, Square Payroll ensures that businesses handle payroll operations flawlessly while also integrating some HR capabilities.

Selecting the right HRIS tool is crucial for businesses to enhance operational efficiency and employee satisfaction. Understanding the specific strengths and differences between Sage HR and Square Payroll will help in making an informed decision.

Sage HR Overview

Sage HR specializes in providing a robust suite of HR tools aimed at solving various HR challenges. From employee management and performance tracking to leave management and shift scheduling, Sage HR addresses the needs of HR departments comprehensively.

Key Features

  • Employee Database: Centralize all employee information with easy access and update capabilities.
  • Leave Management: Automate and streamline the process of managing employee leave requests.
  • Performance Management: Conduct performance reviews, set objectives, and evaluate employee performance effectively.
  • Shift Scheduling: Create and manage employee schedules, ensuring optimal staffing levels.
  • Expense Management: Simplify the expense claim process with tracking and approval workflows.
  • Onboarding: Facilitate smooth onboarding processes for new hires with customizable onboarding checklists and documentation.
  • Reports and Analytics: Generate insightful HR reports to analyze trends and make data-driven decisions.

Square Payroll Overview 

Square Payroll stands out as a user-friendly online payroll service designed with small businesses in mind. With seamless integration to Square's broader ecosystem, it offers a straightforward yet effective way to manage payroll and some HR functionalities.

Key Features

  • Automated Payroll: Calculate and distribute employee and contractor payments accurately and on time.
  • Tax Filing: Automatically handle tax withholdings, filings, and payments.
  • Timecard Integration: Integrate with Square's timecard app to import employee hours directly.
  • Employee Self-Service: Allow employees to view their own pay stubs and manage personal information.
  • Direct Deposit: Facilitate direct deposit payments for both employees and contractors.
  • Benefits Management: Manage employee benefits such as health insurance through integrated benefits providers.
  • Reports: Access to various payroll reports for better financial oversight and compliance.


Both Sage HR and Square Payroll aim to simplify and streamline the complex processes involved in HR and payroll management. Here are some of their similarities:

  • Centralized Employee Information: Both tools offer a centralized system to manage employee information, making it easier to maintain up-to-date records.
  • Leave and Attendance Management: Each platform provides functionalities to manage leave requests and track attendance, contributing to better workforce management.
  • Integration Capabilities: Both integrate with other tools and platforms, enhancing their utility and making them more versatile.
  • Self-Service Portals: Both provide employee self-service portals, enabling employees to update personal information, view pay details, and access HR resources.
  • Compliance: Each tool helps businesses stay compliant with relevant laws and regulations, such as tax filings and labor laws.


Despite their similarities, Sage HR and Square Payroll serve distinct functions and showcase unique features:

  • Core Focus: Sage HR is a comprehensive HR management solution, while Square Payroll focuses primarily on payroll management with some HR features.
  • Feature Depth: Sage HR offers more in-depth HR functionalities such as performance management, onboarding, and expense tracking, which are not available in Square Payroll.
  • Target Audience: Sage HR is aimed at businesses seeking extensive HR capabilities, while Square Payroll is tailored for small businesses primarily in need of a reliable and easy-to-use payroll system.
  • Scheduling: Sage HR offers robust shift scheduling capabilities, which is not a core feature of Square Payroll.
  • Tax Management: Square Payroll excels in automating tax filings and payments, a feature more prominent compared to Sage HR's offerings.
  • Onboarding and Training: Sage HR’s dedicated onboarding and training tools add a layer of functionality that Square Payroll doesn’t emphasize.

Pros and Cons

Sage HR


  • Comprehensive HR functionalities covering a wide range of HR needs.
  • Helps in performance management and employee development.
  • Strong focus on onboarding and training enhances new hire integration.
  • Effective leave and expense management features.
  • Detailed reports and analytics for data-driven decision-making.


  • Might be more than needed for businesses looking solely for payroll solutions.
  • Learning curve may be steeper due to the depth of features.
  • Higher pricing can be a consideration for smaller businesses.

Square Payroll 


  • Simplifies and automates payroll processing efficiently.
  • User-friendly interface with straightforward navigation.
  • Excellent integration with other Square products and timecard apps.
  • Automatic tax handling reduces administrative burden.
  • Designed for small businesses, ensuring cost-effectiveness.


  • Limited HR functionalities compared to Sage HR.
  • Lacks comprehensive features such as performance management and onboarding tools.
  • Not ideal for businesses with more complex HR needs.

Use Cases

  • Sage HR Use Cases:
  • Small to medium-sized businesses looking for a full-fledged HR management solution.
  • Organizations needing detailed performance management and employee development tools.
  • Companies wanting to streamline onboarding and training processes.
  • Businesses requiring robust leave management and shift scheduling capabilities.

  • Square Payroll Use Cases:
  • Small businesses needing a straightforward, efficient payroll solution.
  • Organizations leveraging Square’s ecosystem for integrated timecard and payroll functionalities.
  • Businesses prioritizing ease of use and automated tax compliance.
  • Companies with minimal HR needs but requiring reliable payroll processing.


In comparing Sage HR and Square Payroll, it's clear that both tools serve distinct purposes within the HRIS landscape. 

Sage HR shines as a comprehensive HR management system perfect for businesses that need an array of HR functionalities, from performance management to onboarding and training. Its depth and breadth of features make it suitable for organizations focusing on developing their HR practices comprehensively.

Square Payroll, meanwhile, stands out as an optimal choice for small businesses looking for efficient and user-friendly payroll processing. Its integration capabilities with other Square products and automated tax compliance features provide a seamless payroll experience without overwhelming the user with additional HR functions.

For businesses needing a robust HR suite, Sage HR is the recommended option. However, for small enterprises seeking focused payroll management, Square Payroll is the ideal choice. The final decision should align with the specific needs and scale of the business, ensuring the chosen tool addresses the most critical pain points effectively.

Key takeaways 🔑🥡🍕

Written by
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.

Learn more tools and terminology re: workplace knowledge