Back to Reference
No items found.
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.
Watch a demoTake a product tour
June 6, 2024
XX min read

IntelliHR vs Square Payroll


When it comes to choosing the right HRIS tools, finding one that best suits your organization's needs is crucial. This comparison will focus on two prominent tools: IntelliHR and Square Payroll.

IntelliHR, a Humanforce company, is an intelligent people platform revolutionizing human resources management by empowering global HR leaders to foster inclusive, engaging, high-performing, and aligned workplace cultures. Designed for today's hybrid work environment, IntelliHR's cloud-based platform seamlessly enhances employee engagement, performance, and retention. With ease of implementation, best-of-breed integrations, and robust data-driven capabilities, IntelliHR is the preferred HR software for hundreds of forward-thinking organizations and 70,000 users globally.

Square Payroll, on the other hand, is an online payroll service trusted by small businesses. It offers straightforward payroll processing, making it easier for small businesses to manage their payroll obligations efficiently.

Comparing HRIS tools is essential to determine which platform is best for your specific organizational needs, whether it's advanced HR management or simple payroll processing.

IntelliHR Overview

Key Features

  • Employee Lifecycle Management: IntelliHR offers comprehensive tools to manage the entire employee lifecycle, from onboarding to offboarding.
  • Performance Management: It provides robust performance management features, including continuous feedback, goal tracking, and performance reviews.
  • Employee Engagement: IntelliHR includes tools to enhance employee engagement through surveys, feedback systems, and pulse checks.
  • Analytics and Reporting: The platform offers advanced analytics and custom reporting capabilities to derive insights and drive decision-making.
  • Integration Capabilities: IntelliHR integrates seamlessly with various third-party applications, ensuring a cohesive HR ecosystem.
  • Compliance Management: Automated compliance tracking helps organizations stay ahead of legal requirements and reduce risks.

Square Payroll Overview

Key Features

  • Payroll Processing: Square Payroll simplifies payroll calculations and automates the payroll process, ensuring timely and accurate payments.
  • Tax Filing: The platform automatically handles tax filings and payments, easing the burden on small business owners.
  • Employee Benefits: Square Payroll offers options to manage benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and workers' compensation.
  • Time Tracking Integration: The tool integrates with Square's time tracking features, providing a seamless payroll experience.
  • Accessibility: Square Payroll can be accessed easily via mobile devices, ensuring payroll management is convenient and on-the-go.
  • Direct Deposits: Employees receive their payments directly into their bank accounts, enhancing convenience.


Both IntelliHR and Square Payroll serve important functions in human resource management but do so with different focal points. Here's what they have in common:

  • Cloud-Based: Both platforms are cloud-based, providing accessibility from anywhere with an internet connection.
  • User-Friendly Interface: Both IntelliHR and Square Payroll are designed to be intuitive and user-friendly, reducing the learning curve.
  • Integration Capabilities: Both tools support integrations with other commonly used business applications and tools.
  • Automated Processes: They automate repetitive tasks, thereby saving time and reducing potential errors.
  • Compliance Features: Both platforms offer tools to help ensure compliance with relevant regulations and legal requirements.


While they share some similarities, IntelliHR and Square Payroll differ significantly in their primary functions and offerings:

  • Focus Areas: IntelliHR is designed primarily for comprehensive HR management, focusing on employee engagement, performance, and lifecycle management. Square Payroll, however, is centered around simplifying payroll processing for small businesses.
  • Target Audience: IntelliHR targets mid-sized to larger organizations with more complex HR needs, while Square Payroll is aimed at small to medium-sized businesses looking for straightforward payroll solutions.
  • Feature Depth: IntelliHR offers more complex and detailed features for performance management, employee engagement, and analytics. Square Payroll focuses on the essential elements of payroll processing, tax filing, and basic employee benefits.
  • Implementation: IntelliHR can involve a more intricate implementation process due to its vast capabilities, whereas Square Payroll is typically quicker to set up and use.
  • Cost Structure: Given its advanced features, IntelliHR may come at a higher price point compared to Square Payroll, which is typically more budget-friendly for small businesses.

Pros and Cons



  • Comprehensive HR management capabilities
  • Advanced analytics and reporting tools
  • Seamless third-party integrations
  • Strong employee engagement features
  • Effective performance management tools


  • Higher cost compared to simpler HRIS tools
  • More complex implementation process
  • Potentially overwhelming for small businesses with basic HR needs

Square Payroll


  • Simplifies payroll processing
  • Automatic tax filing and payments
  • Cost-effective solution for small businesses
  • User-friendly and quick to implement
  • Integrates with Square's broader ecosystem (e.g., time tracking)


  • Limited HR management capabilities beyond payroll
  • Basic analytics and reporting features
  • May not scale well for larger organizations with complex HR needs

Use Cases


  • Ideal for mid-sized to larger organizations seeking a comprehensive HR management platform.
  • Suitable for companies focused on improving employee engagement, performance, and retention.
  • Useful for organizations seeking advanced analytics and reporting capabilities to drive HR decisions.
  • Fits companies that need robust integration capabilities with other systems for a cohesive HR ecosystem.

Square Payroll

  • Perfect for small businesses needing a straightforward payroll solution.
  • Ideal for small to medium-sized companies looking to automate payroll and tax filing processes.
  • Suitable for businesses already using Square's ecosystem, such as their point-of-sale and time tracking tools.
  • Beneficial for organizations seeking a cost-effective payroll solution without advanced HR management features.


In comparing IntelliHR and Square Payroll, it’s evident that both tools cater to different needs within the HR and payroll spectrum.

IntelliHR is ideal for organizations that need a comprehensive HR management platform with advanced features for employee engagement, performance management, and detailed reporting. It excels in environments where HR processes are integral to the company’s success and requires a robust, integrated system to manage the employee lifecycle.

Square Payroll, on the other hand, is the go-to solution for small businesses needing a straightforward, efficient payroll tool. It simplifies payroll processing, automates tax filings, and integrates well with other Square tools, making it a highly convenient and cost-effective option.

When choosing between IntelliHR and Square Payroll, consider the specific needs of your organization. If your business requires a holistic HR solution with advanced analytics and engagement tools, IntelliHR is likely the better choice. For simple, efficient payroll management, especially within a small business context, Square Payroll is the optimal solution.

Key takeaways 🔑🥡🍕

Written by
Search everything, get answers anywhere with Guru.

Learn more tools and terminology re: workplace knowledge